Can Governments Afford to Rely on One Network?
Nov 22, 2026
Military users of Starshield in Ukraine were recently reminded how risky it is to rely on one network alone. The terminals lost connectivity whenever they were moving faster than about 100 miles per hour, and the disruption was felt by Ukrainian units operating in the field. On the battlefield, even a short loss of connectivity can determine the outcome of an entire operation. Service was restored within a couple of weeks, but customer confidence had already been shaken. News like this spreads quickly in defense circles and ministries, particularly when a military system is involved. Many buyers saw it as proof that a link outside their control can be restricted with hardly any notice, and this view is now influencing how procurement offices evaluate every satellite contract.
Credit: Google
An analyst at ABI Research said that Starshield is owned and controlled by the US government, and that any limits on its use are set in Washington. That is what makes buyers uneasy. Payment does not purchase control. Germany is among those paying for it, with a contract that has months left to run, and its foreign minister said that the restrictions had to be lifted. For governments footing the bill, the concern was less about the outage as such and more about the possibility that a service could be limited without any warning. Europe began to consider how much of its vital communications it could safely leave in the hands of someone else.
Money Starts Flowing Toward a Second Network
The concept of a backup ceased to be theoretical in a matter of moments. Investors took notice first, and shares in Eutelsat jumped about 25 percent in one week, with a one-day gain of about 19 percent. The move pointed to genuine and lasting demand for a second network. Eutelsat owns OneWeb, a constellation of about 650 satellites that is already in orbit and serving customers. That head start is significant, as most other options are still being built and launched. Timing is everything when a customer wants a second route now and not in five years.
The Pentagon had made the same call months before the disruption. Under the program that buys proliferated low Earth orbit service for the Joint Force, the first order went to Starshield and the second went to OneWeb Technologies. Since then, Eutelsat Network Solutions, the trade name of OneWeb Technologies, has announced an award that it estimates at more than 60 million dollars over two years for OneWeb airtime, deployable terminals and alternative positioning, navigation and timing. Its president and chief executive, Ian Canning, stated that today’s military operations require communications that are agile, resilient and available anywhere in the world. The amount is modest in Pentagon terms, but the decision itself is more telling than the number. The military customer that had the most access to Starshield decided to retain a second network, and it selected one that was already in orbit.
Europe Commits to Its Own Safety Net
France has taken a similar step with an armed forces contract that gives its military priority access to OneWeb and is valued at up to 1 billion euros by a British think tank. Priority access suggests that the French military would be served first if capacity gets tight. That’s a hedge in the most literal sense, as it pays for a second path in case the first one doesn’t work out. Governments don’t invest that much in a network they consider a curiosity. It also informs other European buyers that a working alternative is already on the shelf, and real satellites and real terminals are behind it. When one big customer signs, others tend to follow.
Credit: ESA
IRIS² is Europe’s own constellation, designed to provide a permanent solution. Its first launches are expected at the end of this decade, and the project is designed to maintain a critical service under European control. For now, there is nothing on that network that carries traffic, so it’s still at the planning and early commitment stage. Yet the political argument for it is much stronger than it was a few months ago. Until it flies, OneWeb is filling the void, and that’s why both names continue to be mentioned in the same breath. Now every procurement officer in the region has a real-life example to show why the project is important, and that’s a hard argument to dismiss.
Launch Capacity Decides How Far Hedging Goes
Taiwan’s space agency has begun preliminary discussions with a few partners on a joint network of over 300 communications satellites that would be developed by private firms. NATO has also begun implementing a mechanism that lets militaries book slots on commercial rockets through spaceports in member nations and South Korea. These initiatives show that governments are now treating connectivity as infrastructure that requires redundancy. The weak spot is launch, as rockets are scarce and the launch dates of several large programs are slipping. Clayton Swope of the Center for Strategic and International Studies said that the launch bottleneck is real and will get worse. That’s why a second network is only as real as the rocket that carries it.
There is a good case for saying that these early steps matter more than their size suggests. An award of more than 60 million dollars and a round of early talks are only a beginning, but they show that buyers want a second route, and OneWeb is the one already in service. In addition, the same ABI analyst noted that jurisdiction and the ability to limit service are becoming clear scoring factors in procurement. Such a change first becomes visible in tender documents, and OneWeb and IRIS² seem to be much closer to the shortlist than they were prior to the Starshield disruption. Hedging is no longer a fringe concept, and the firms that provide a viable alternative will be considered seriously by governments and investors alike.
